The Productivity Paradox: Why We Get More Done When We’re Busier

Brian Brandow
Published:
productivity paradox busier done
productivity paradox busier done
Some of the links included in this article are from our sponsors. Read our Advertiser Disclosure.
I recently came across a video that perfectly captured something I’ve experienced but never fully understood. The speaker, Advice with Erin, explained why many of us are actually more productive when we have less time – a concept known as Parkinson’s law.
This psychological principle states that work expands to fill the time you give it. It’s why someone with a full-time job can somehow manage to walk their dog, hit the gym, cook dinner, clean up, call family, and still get to bed at a reasonable hour. Yet when that same person becomes unemployed with endless free time, accomplishing even one of those tasks feels like a victory.

The Freedom Trap

**Having unlimited time is actually a productivity killer.** I’ve noticed this in my own life too. When faced with an entire day of freedom, I often find myself trapped in a cycle of procrastination – scrolling through social media, snacking mindlessly, or taking hours to complete simple tasks that would normally take minutes.
The contrast is striking. When our schedules are packed, we somehow find efficiency we didn’t know we had. Twenty emails that would take all day during unemployment get knocked out in an hour when we’re busy. A closet that would take all weekend to organize gets sorted in two hours when we have dinner plans later.

Why This Happens

The psychology behind this phenomenon makes perfect sense when you think about it. Our brains respond to constraints. Without deadlines or structure, we lack the external pressure that forces us to prioritize and focus.
When time is unlimited:
* Tasks expand unnecessarily
* Decision-making becomes harder
* Perfectionism creeps in
* Distractions multiply
When we’re busy, our brain shifts into a different gear. We become ruthlessly efficient because we have to be. There’s no time for perfectionism or overthinking.

Reclaiming Your Productivity

The solution to this paradox is counterintuitive but effective: **if you want to be more productive, give yourself less time.** This doesn’t mean you need to fill every minute with work, but rather that you need to create structure and boundaries.
Here are practical ways to apply this principle:
1. Set timers for tasks (25 minutes to clean the kitchen, not “whenever”)
2. Schedule appointments throughout your day
3. Book workout classes instead of planning to “go to the gym sometime”
4. Create artificial deadlines for projects
5. Consider volunteer work or part-time gigs to create structure
I’ve found that when I block my calendar with specific time slots for tasks – even personal ones like reading or meditation – I’m far more likely to actually do them than when I leave my schedule open.

The Power of Constraints

There’s something freeing about constraints. When your brain knows it has limited time, it naturally becomes more efficient. You stop overthinking and start doing. You make decisions faster. You focus on what matters.
This principle applies beyond just daily tasks. Creative work, business projects, and even personal goals often benefit from tight constraints rather than open-ended timelines.
Next time you find yourself with a wide-open schedule and nothing getting done, try this experiment: give yourself half the time you think you need for a task. You might be surprised at how quickly and effectively you complete it when the clock is ticking.
The most productive people aren’t those with the most time – they’re those who use their limited time most effectively. By understanding and applying Parkinson’s law, we can all reclaim our productivity, even in seasons with more freedom and flexibility.